Keysnet.com: Oil drilling bill faces tough going

http://www.keysnet.com/2010/03/20/200966/oil-drilling-bill-faces-tough.html

Oil drilling bill faces tough going

But opponents keep a watchful eye on future House Speaker

By KEVIN WADLOW

kwadlow@keynoter.com

Posted – Saturday, March 20, 2010 06:21 PM EDT

No Drilling Photo A group of more than 200 oil-drilling opponents form on Key West’s Smathers Beach to show their feelings in a Feb. 13 rally as part of the statewide Hands Across the Sand project.

Moves to loosen Florida law on offshore oil drilling face steep obstacles in the current session of the Florida Legislature, but drilling foes are keeping a wary watch anyway.     Florida Senate bill, SB 2622, has been introduced that would allow drilling as close as one mile along some coastlines, or three miles out if the nearest community objects.

But Senate President Jeff Atwater of North Palm Beach blocked a similar bill in the Senate last year, and has indicated he plans to block it again.

“Unless something changes, I do not see a bill coming out of the legislature this year,” said Paul Johnson, a Tallahassee policy advisor to Reef Relief. Johnson is a former president of Reef Relief, based in Key West.    “The Senate president has made it clear that he does not intend to bring the [oil-drilling] bill up,” Johnson said.   “But we still need to keep track of it pretty closely,” he added. “When the Legislature is in session, anything can happen.”

Monroe County State Rep. Ron Saunders agreed with Johnson’s assessment.    “It sounds like the Senate is probably going to hold it up this year. There’s not even a bill introduced in the House yet,” Saunders said.    “It’s hard to know anything until there is a House bill, but its chances [of passage] probably are pretty slim.”    However, Rep. Dean Cannon of Winter Park, among the Legislature’s most vocal supporters of oil exploration, has been selected as the next Speaker of the House, which means he drives the agenda for the 2011 session.   “When the Speaker-designate is pushing something, there’s always a chance it could happen,” Saunders said.

Sen. Mike Haridopolos of Melbourne, who introduced SB 2622 this year, is the Senate’s president-designate.   The Legislature’s session ends April 30.    After Cannon and Haridopolos take over leadership positions next year, Saunders said, it means “very powerful legislators” will be advocating in the 2011 session for increased oil exploration in Florida waters.

Cannon told the Tallahassee Democrat newspaper that he will include requirements in a drilling bill that any oil exploration or pumping activity not create “a visual blight” for coastal communities that base their tourism economies on scenic waterfronts.

The Florida House passed a bill last year to allow exploration and drilling in state waters, but the bill died after no action by the Senate.

Legislators asked the Century Commission for a Sustainable Florida, based at the state Collins Center for Public Policy, to review the issue of drilling in the Gulf of Mexico.

The report was released earlier this week, giving both sides in the drilling debate some comfort.

The report concluded that Florida may not have enough submerged oil in its Gulf waters to create widespread pumping like that seen off Texas and Louisiana coasts. Any oil removed from Florida waters would not be enough to result in cheaper gas, the report noted.

The report acknowledges that the danger to shorelines from a major drilling-related spill probably is overstated by opponents.

Offshore drilling rigs in the Gulf were damaged by the 2004-05 hurricane seasons, the report notes, but the most significant spills were caused by flooding of onshore facilities.

However, it also points out that a single major spill could be highly damaging, especially to the Florida Keys marine ecosystem and the state’s East Coast, where currents would carry the spill.

“Spills are not our biggest concern, although a spill would be horrible,” said Millard McCleary, program director for Reef Relief. “What’s going to hurt is that basic drilling creates sludge that will be carried into the mangroves and to the reef every day.”

The Key West City Commission and the citizen advisory board for the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary have passed resolutions that protest any move to remove protections for Keys waters, “some of the environmentally and ecologically sensitive areas in the world.”

Tampa Bay.com: Cannon say Oil & gas bill may not get done, but we’ll get policy right.

http://blogs.tampabay.com/buzz/2010/03/cannon-oil-and-gas-bill-may-not-get-done-but-well-get-policy-right.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+tampabaycom%2Fblogs%2Fbuzz+%28The+Buzz+|+tampabay.com%29
 
March 19, 2010

Cannon: Oil and gas bill may not get done but we’ll get policy right

After concluding the House’s final workshop on the exploration of oil and gas drilling off Florida coasts, Rep. Dean Cannon, R-Winter Park, outlined three areas he expects the House bill to include when it is released in two weeks.
1. Preventing “any visual impact to our beaches” that could “cause visual blight.”
 2. Don’t disrupt military activity. He said he wants to give the military “essentially veto power over any drilling activity.”
3. Recognizing improvements in technology, such as the opportunity to use directional
drilling.  “Advancements in technology have resolved many of the concerns that were appropriately fears 20 years ago.”
Cannon also said he believes the bill should authorize the Governor and Cabinet, sittig as the Board of Trustess for the Internal Improvement Trust Fund, to develop the oil and gas permitting process.
Cannon said he plans to have a House bill emerge on week six of the eight-week session but is not concerned if it doesn’t pass this year becasue he is prepared to come back next year “with even a better bill.” Senate President Jeff Atwater and Gov. Charlie Crist have both said they oppose opening Florida’s coast to oil drilling in Florida waters.
“Whether or not it passes at the end of the day I’m less worried about because if we get the policy right, it won’t matter this year or next year,” Cannon said.

 Posted by Mary Ellen Klas at 11:30:45 AM on March 19, 2010

Special thanks to Richard Charter

Oil & Gas Journal: MMS receives bids for Lease Sale 213 in Central Gulf of Mexico

http://www.ogj.com/index/article-display/6296264352/articles/oil-gas-journal/exploration-development-2/2010/03/mms-receives_bids/QP129867/cmpid=EnlDailyMarch172010.html
Oil and Gas Journal
MMS receives bids for Lease Sale 213 in central gulf

Mar 16, 2010
By OGJ editors
HOUSTON, Mar. 16 — Sixty-seven companies submitted 642 bids on 468 tracts that are being offered Mar. 17 off Louisiana, Mississippi, and Alabama in the central Gulf of Mexico by the US Minerals Management Service.

A total of 295 tracts in water depths greater than 1,300 ft received bids in Lease Sale 213. The sealed bids will be opened and publicly read Mar. 17 in the New Orleans Superdome.

“The industry’s interest in tomorrow’s Central Gulf oil and gas lease sale demonstrates the importance of the deepwater gulf to future energy development,” said Lars Herbst, MMS Gulf of Mexico regional director, who will preside over the sale.

Special thanks to Richard Charter

Creative Loafing: The Fight against Nearshore Oil Drilling in Florida isn’t Nearly Over

http://blogs.creativeloafing.com/dailyloaf/2010/03/15/the-fight-against-nearshore-oil-drilling-in-florida-isnt-nearly-over/
special thanks to RIchard Charter and Creative Loafing
The fight against nearshore oil drilling in Florida isn’t nearly over
March 15, 2010 at 3:35 pm by Cathy Harrelson

The last year could be considered a success in local environmental activism. After years of support for these measures down the west coast, and varied stakeholder input across the Tampa Bay watershed, the Suncoast Sierra Club headed the coalition that created the space for passage of strong, local fertilizer and landscape management ordinances. These measures passed in Gulfport, unanimously in St. Petersburg, and in January of 2010, the strongest ordinance in Florida was passed by the Pinellas County Board of County Commissioners in a 6-1, vote. (A video of the meeting can be found  here.) These actions are critical to the health of our ponds, streams, rivers, Gulf and Tampa Bay. Algae fed by excessive nitrogen runoff contributes to the explosive harmful algal blooms like Red Tide and the 14-mile long brown goo that lived and spread across Tampa Bay last year.

Suncoast Sierra Club continues to participate in this process by working for ordinances in Hillsborough and Manatee Counties, as well as through participation in the Tampa Bay Estuary Program’s educational development and outreach. (The TBEP Urban Fertilizer Use information is located on their website.) These regulations will be most effective if we can effect a sea change in the way residents view their own yards & lawns, and by taking personal responsibility for learning how to do it right. Sierra Club has committed to assisting TBEP and Pinellas County with that ongoing effort. With help from our friends in the Audubon Society, the Florida Native Plant Society, the Pinellas County Extension, Green Florida, and many others, we add our voices to the growing chorus of folks calling for “Food Not Lawns,’ creating Florida yards and neighborhoods using native and Florida-friendly plants, and shifting to more sustainable and affordable approaches to our green spaces.

As usual, in 2009 our Coastal Task Force had to perform an about-face from fertilizer to offshore and nearshore oil drilling. As a member of the Protect Florida’s Beaches coalition,  we helped successfully lobby in last year’s Florida Legislative Session to put the brakes on nearshore (3-10 miles) drilling proposals. But as we’ve come to know, this is the “threat that never dies.” Year after year we’ve stepped up to testify and lobby against lifting the ban on drilling in the Federal Waters of the eastern Gulf, the area from 10-236 miles. Year after year we’ve held the Feds at bay, through the efforts of many, including U.S. Congressman C.W. Bill Young. Congressman Young has been the guy holding back that oil-slicked tide for decades in the U.S. House, supported by many other elected officials, businesses, environmentalists and citizens. We must monitor and stay ready to defend against the continued issue of lifting the moratorium on drilling in Federal waters – language that has been surreptitiously added to the Senate versions of the Federal Climate Bill. Our own Senator Bill Nelson has threatened to filibuster if the Gulf drilling language isn’t removed from the Climate Bill. (Go Senator Nelson!)

Now, the issue has expanded. There are some in the Florida Legislature who have become mysteriously and rabidly attached to selling Florida’s future to drilling interests in our nearshore waters.The iconic enemy of our coastal environment and coastal tourism is the oil rig, with its polluting drilling operations and threats of larger spills. This enemy could now could appear 3-10 miles off our coastlines. This issue has become so front and center that a grassroots effort to combat it was conceived late last year and executed on February 13th. Hands Across the Sand was a simple, grassroots event that pulled 10,000+ citizens and politicos of diverse economic, political and business backgrounds out to the beaches on a cold, windy day. Our local coalition, Love Tourists Not Drilling, organized 3,000 people on Pinellas County beaches alone! It was an amazing sight and an incredible experience of community.

So now what? Coastal drilling bills have been filed in the House and Senate of the Florida Legislature for the 2010 session. Whether or not these bills come forward through the maze of largely mid-Florida, conservative-led committees remains to be seen, but it is something we will all be following in the days ahead. Though this is often debated, we believe the non-coastal leadership in the legislature is determined to push this through this year. Why?

1. The non-coastal, ultra-conservative leadership has control now, but elections can change things (at least we’d like to think so). They will want to strike while the iron is hot. Even the President mentioned oil drilling in his State of the Union Speech. However, it is notable that he mentioned drilling once, while he showcased his support for building a renewable energy future 12 times.

2. We currently have a governor who very publicly came out in favor of coastal drilling during the 2008 Presidential campaign, lessening the prospect of a veto. Whereas, all three leading gubernatorial candidates, Sink, McCollum & Dockery have come out against coastal drilling.

3. The push toward renewables is gaining strength through targeted stimulus funding, tax credits & rebates, constantly-improving technology and a slowly-dawning recognition by financial institutions of the profitable role they can play in bringing renewable technologies to mainstream America. It all screams the same thing: “Oil is over.” Say it with me, “Oil is over.” Investment guru Warren Buffett talked about reaching peak 0il in 2008. Like him or not, he has seldom been wrong. And that was 2 years ago! Even the oil industry is talking about 2030 or 2035 as the end of oil. The impetus to change is right here, right now, and they know they must grab every last subsidized dollar they can out of Oil.

4. The increasingly insistent effects of Climate Change will continue to lap at our doors here in Florida. Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions will again take center stage as the U.N.’s International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) will update its 2007 climate change and sea level rise report with a resounding: “Oh golly, Florida, you’re in deepŠwater.” This will make that pesky fossil-fuel burning thing even more distasteful than it is now. Oil is over. Just keep saying it.

These two issues are emblematic of a larger battle for sustainability versus consumption as the opposing economic models for our communities, our nation and our planet. Change is in the air, and the crack in the earth is generated from the ground up. That means us – you and me. National policy was lacking for years and it’s safe to say any success at that level will be diluted at best. The rubber hits the road right here in your home, your car, your yard, your life. Does this require duty and personal responsibility? Yes. Is it also an opportunity to make a real difference? You betcha. What we do here pushes up and out to affect the larger community in Tampa Bay, Florida and beyond. Contact your council members, your county commissioners, your state legislators. Stay informed through our new website, www.suncoastsierra.org, and Facebook page and the networking opportunities we’re developing. Sign up for our e-newsletter. Check out Hands Across the Sand on the web and Love Tourists Not Drilling on Facebook. Let’s get this party started.

Cathy Harrelson
Conservation and Coastal Task Force Chair for the Suncoast Sierra Club

Sarasota Herald Tribune: Commission finds no Strong Case for Drilling off Florida

http://www.heraldtribune.com/article/20100316/ARTICLE/3161066/2416/NEWS?Title=Commission-no-strong-case-for-drilling-off-Florida
Sarasota Herald Tribune
No Strong Case For Drilling
Commission: No strong case for drilling off Florida

By Jeremy Wallace
H-T Political Writer

Published: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 at 1:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 at 12:25 a.m.

Opening Florida’s Gulf Coast to oil drilling would have almost no impact on prices at the pump or on the state’s ongoing budget problems, a nonpartisan commission told a key committee of the Legislature on Monday.

While the House has heard similar arguments from environmental groups and others opposed to drilling, the report was significant because it came from the Century Commission for a Sustainable Florida, created by the Legislature five years ago to study Florida’s long-term future on issues like water resources, growth management and energy.

“Lifting the moratoriums in both federal and state waters would have no discernible impact on petroleum prices at the retail level,” said a draft report presented to the House Select Policy Council on Strategic & Economic Planning.

The minimal impact at the pump is largely due to how little oil is thought to exist within the 3 to 10 miles off Florida’s coastline that the Legislature has considered opening to drilling.

The Century Commission report shows that the best estimates for total oil reserves within 10 miles of the shore are 110 million barrels. Tapping every barrel of that oil would last the nation less than one week. The United States consumes about 20 million barrels a day, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

The report is sure to become a rallying cry for those who say the risk to Florida’s environment and tourist industry far outweighs the energy potential.

The Century Commission report also shows that oil drilling will not produce a windfall for the cash-strapped state government.
Other Gulf Coast states that already allow oil drilling and natural gas discoveries receive less than $200 million a year in revenue. In Texas, the state government receives $52 million a year on average and Louisiana brought in $98 million in 2009.

Florida’s annual budget is about $69 billion.

“It doesn’t make much of a case for going forward,” State Rep. Keith Fitzgerald, D-Sarasota, said of the report.

However, the report also pokes holes in the assumption that drilling would put Florida at great risk of an oil spill.

Frank Alcock, a New College of Florida associate professor who helped write the Century Commission’s report, said oil spills are a “low probability” because of the advancement in oil drilling technology.
He said most of the tar balls that wash up on Texas beaches — often cited by environmental groups as evidence of the threat of spills — are from natural seepage from the ocean floor and not from drilling or transporting of oil.

The Century Commission is playing a critical role in guiding the Legislature on offshore oil drilling.
Senate President Jeff Atwater, R-Palm Beach County, called on the 15-member Century Commission to wade through the rhetoric from both sides of the oil drilling debate and present lawmakers with unbiased research to determine whether the state should pursue expanded oil drilling.

Last year, the House passed legislation that would have allowed the governor and Cabinet to approve oil drilling leases within 10 miles of shore. The bill died, though, when the Florida Senate refused to pick up the issue.

Rep. Dean Cannon, R-Winter Park, who proposed the House bill last year, is expected to propose a similar bill this year.
Atwater told the News Service of Florida that the Century Commission’s findings help shape the debate on whether to allow drilling. He said the Legislature must now answer the question of whether there is enough to be gained by taking on the risks of drilling.

The state oil drilling debate comes as Congress continues to debate a U.S. Senate proposal that would allow oil drilling in international waters starting at 45 miles from Florida coastline.

Currently, the federal government bans drilling within 232 miles of Tampa Bay. The state also has a ban on drilling within state waters.

special thanks to Richard Charter

"Be the change you want to see in the world." Mahatma Gandhi